Is morality dependent on religion

Because these definitions of natural and moral good produce a possible gap between the two, we need some way to believe that morality and happiness are coincident.

I hope everyone is clear on the distinction I mean to make here between religion and God. How are we to go about determining what is right and what is wrong. The Theory of Natural Law gives a different answer.

The scriptural passage that comes closest to making a specific judgment about the moral status of fetuses occurs in the 21st chapter of Exodus. Conservative Christians sometimes say that, regardless of how secular thought might view the fetus, the Christian view is that the fetus is a human being from its very beginning.

Is Morality Dependent on Religion

For example, some vampire bats fail to feed on prey some nights while others manage to consume a surplus. But the connection of the highest human state with the divine is pervasive in the text.

But there are also implications for human conduct.

Is Morality Dependent on Religion

Natural law theory has also been used, however, to support moral views that are more contentious. They are making up their minds about the moral issues first and then interpreting the Scriptures, or church tradition, in such a way as to support the moral conclusion they have already reached.

If the god does not care about what is not divine for this would be to become like what is not divinethe highest and most god-like human also does not care about other human beings except to the degree they contribute to his own best state.

The reason is not that they have proven to be better or wiser than other people - as a group, they seem to be neither better nor worse than the rest of us.

Religion and Morality

Humans consequently evolved "pro-social" emotions, such as feelings of empathy or guilt, in response to these moral behaviors. It is true that the notion of obligation makes most sense against the background of command.

God is setting up a kind of covenant by which humans will be blessed if they obey the commands God gives them. If this option is true then morality becomes arbitrary. In After Virtue he is still influenced by a Hegelian historicism, and holds that the only way to settle rival knowledge claims is to see how successfully each can account for the shape taken by its rivals.

To meet the Other is to have the idea of Infinity Ethics and Infinity, 90—1.

Morality and religion

Thomas Hobbes — said that all reality is bodily including Godand all events are motions in space. Similarly, it may be that sex does produce babies, but it does not follow that sex ought or ought not to be engaged in only for that purpose.

Humans are a remarkably vain species. In his homily on I John 4: Many of the central figures in the Reformation were humanists in the Renaissance sense where there is no implication of atheism. The first table concerns our obligations to God directly, to worship God alone and keep God's name holy, and keep the Sabbath.

In that context what we are trying to address is the question of what would be an adequate foundation for morality. But the covenant that God makes with Noah after the flood is applicable to the whole human race, and universal scope is explicit in the Wisdom books, which make a continual connection between how we should live and how we were created as human beings.

He points to the spirit who gives him commands about what not to do Apology, 31dand we learn later that he found it significant that this voice never told him to stop conducting his trial in the way that in fact led to his death Ibid.

A study by Gregory S. This moral sense responds to examples of benevolence with approbation and a unique kind of pleasure, and benevolence is the only thing it responds to, as it were the only signal it picks up.

But the practical argument was decisive for him, though he held that it was possible to be morally good without being a theist, despite such a position being rationally unstable. This does not mean that we have no natural end or telos, but that this end is related to the intention of God in the same way a human artisan intends his or her products to have a certain purpose see Harechapter 2.

Religion and Morality

But this was only a reason to accept it, if in general it is reasonable to accept certain principles such as the Uniformity of Nature which are not self-evident and which cannot be proved, but which bring order and coherence into a central part of our thought. (21 Marks) There are three main views for Morality and religion: Morality is dependent on religion, morality is Independent of religion and morality is opposed to religion.

There is a myriad of reasons for and against each of these statements. Morality is often referred to religion, as a lot of our laws come from religion; however that doesn’t mean morals are always dependent on religion; as some people believe in autonomy where they believe the principles of morality are based on reason and experience (the morals from society) and not necessarily on religious concepts.

Does Morality Depend on Religion?

Morality and religion

April 30, Ethics - Religion, Philosophy of Religion John Messerly. Why should I be moral? One answer is that if we are moral, the gods will reward us; and if not, the gods will punish us. (21 Marks) There are three main views for Morality and religion: Morality is dependent on religion, morality is Independent of religion and morality is opposed to religion.

There is a myriad of reasons for and against each of these statements. This provides a way to base morality on religion without raising the problems of the divine command theory.

The theory of Natural Law is not a strictly religious approach to the question of morality. It has its origins in Aristotle's theory of ethics and is the idea that everything in nature has a purpose.

Arguments for morality being based on religion Religion is a worldview that gives meaning, purpose and value to the world In contrast to a purely scientific worldview that is silent on values and suggests that human life, all life, the earth and the universe will eventually doomed to end.

Is morality dependent on religion
Rated 3/5 based on 84 review
Is Morality Dependent on Religion - Sample Essays